'Just Not Right': A Republican Governor Challenges Trump's Falsehoods
For Governor Mike DeWine, the recent assaults on Haitians close to his Ohio hometown hit close to home. The repercussions of Trump’s and J.D. Vance’s harsh demonization of legal immigrants are deeply felt as well.
TroibNews 
SPRINGFIELD, Ohio — On a rainy Sunday afternoon, Ohio Governor Mike DeWine and his wife of 57 years, Fran, are seated quietly seven pews back from the altar at St. Raphael’s, a gothic revival church built in the 19th century for Irish and German migrants. Named after the patron saint of travelers, St. Raphael's now holds an afternoon mass in Creole for the 21st-century travelers arriving in Ohio: Haitians.
The DeWines keep to themselves, and most in the sanctuary are unaware of the governor's presence until after the homily when a Haitian layman recognizes him. Curiosity shifts eyes toward the governor, and the congregation rises to give him an ovation. DeWine acknowledges the gesture with a wave before sitting down, heartened to see more Haitians in attendance this week compared to the last, when fear kept many away.
The following morning, the DeWines visit McGregor Metal, a family-run factory that manufactures auto and farm parts. Owner Jamie McGregor has closed the bay doors for safety reasons, as flyers labeling him a “TRAITOR” circulate due to his employment of Haitians and his commendation of their work ethic.
After touring the factory and engaging with a diverse workforce of white Ohioans and Haitians, DeWine joins a discussion at a conference table. The locals praise their co-workers, and one even lightens the mood with a humorous remark about their ancestors. The Haitians express gratitude for their jobs but acknowledge the recent difficulties and the unease surrounding them.
One Haitian, opting to remain anonymous, bravely addresses the governor: “What do they think about the Haitians in Springfield and USA?”
DeWine responds warmly, stating, “Look, people that want to come here and want to work and that are legal, which you are, we welcome you. Everybody, their family came from somewhere. My family, on my father’s side, came from Ireland back in the 1840s.” He reiterates his welcoming stance before inquiring about the challenges they face.
Later that day, DeWine is at the local Bureau of Motor Vehicles, trying to tackle the issues that arise from the growing Haitian population. As he enters the facility, a passerby calls him “a disgrace,” but he remains unfazed. However, inside, frustration builds as he notes the delays in translating driving forms into Creole. “This is not tolerable,” he expresses to his staff, urging them to expedite the process.
DeWine views the challenges as part of a broader “crisis” affecting the area, and he is committed to addressing them. Amid heightened political tensions, especially with immigrant groups being targeted, DeWine's position has become increasingly complex.
While he navigates these issues, DeWine remains focused on solutions, even as he faces pushback from political figures like Senator JD Vance, who uses inflammatory rhetoric against immigrants. DeWine has personal ties to the Haitian community, having quietly supported a Catholic school in one of Port-au-Prince’s poorest neighborhoods for over 20 years.
Mike and Fran DeWine have visited Haiti multiple times and have developed deep connections to its people. They have facilitated fundraising efforts for the Becky DeWine School, named in memory of their late daughter. They dismiss any notion of divine intervention in his current role as governor amidst the unrest in Springfield, emphasizing that he would act similarly for any group of migrants.
DeWine strongly disapproves of claims labeling Haitians as "illegal" immigrants, asserting their lawful status through Temporary Protected Status. He believes the country has historically provided refuge for those fleeing oppression and should continue to do so.
Even as tensions rise, DeWine remains committed to his party's political realities, stating his need to work from within to push for progress. Despite the challenges, he maintains support for Trump while acknowledging the divisive language that has emerged around immigration.
Local leaders, including Mayor Rob Rue, express frustration with the toxic atmosphere cultivated by political rhetoric surrounding Haitian migrants. Tensions surface with increased public safety fears, including a tragic incident involving a Haitian individual. DeWine and Fran empathize with grieving families and emphasize the need for community healing.
As Springfield grapples with its changing demographic landscape, both DeWines witness firsthand the strain on the community. Even as they navigate political dynamics, their focus remains on fostering unity and addressing the everyday needs of their constituents.
The DeWines, well-versed in Ohio's history, reflect on the current challenges facing Springfield. They understand the cyclical nature of immigration and backlash in American history and advocate for a nation that remains a welcoming haven for those seeking opportunity.
In an environment rife with tension and political strife, DeWine voices an enduring belief in the value of immigrants, asserting that their contributions are vital to the country's vitality.As DeWine navigates these complexities, he consistently emphasizes the importance of community engagement and open dialogue. During a recent gathering at a local church, he listens attentively to the concerns of both Haitian immigrants and long-time residents, fostering a sense of solidarity among attendees. It's clear that the governor understands the critical need for communication to bridge the gap between the evolving demographics and the existing population's fears.
Amid these discussions, DeWine highlights initiatives aimed at improving resources for the immigrant community, including language services and emergency support. He acknowledges the existing strain on local institutions, particularly the Bureau of Motor Vehicles, that are struggling to keep up with the volume of new Haitian residents needing assistance. “We have to ensure our systems can accommodate everyone,” he asserts, advocating for accelerating translation services and streamlining processes to ease the burden on all residents.
In Springfield, there’s also a palpable sense of solidarity among many community members who actively support their newly arrived Haitian neighbors. Grassroots organizations, alongside churches and local businesses, are coming together to provide aid and assistance, fostering a sense of belonging among the Haitians. Social gatherings and cultural exchanges are becoming more commonplace, creating a rich dialogue about shared experiences and mutual goals.
DeWine’s outreach extends beyond mere logistical support; he actively champions the contributions of the Haitian community to the local economy. He often cites the hard work and resilience of Haitian immigrants, not only in the manufacturing sector but also in revitalizing local eateries, providing services, and enriching Springfield’s cultural diversity. His commitment to these communities resonates with residents who appreciate the collaborative efforts to nurture unity and pride in their town.
However, DeWine also recognizes that deep-rooted fears and misconceptions persist. He openly addresses the misinformation spread by certain political figures, asserting that the narrative surrounding immigrants has often been mischaracterized. He believes in promoting a more nuanced understanding among constituents, which includes education on the history and contributions of immigrant groups in Ohio.
To further this cause, DeWine pushes for educational programs aimed at children and adults alike that highlight the benefits of diversity, fostering empathy and understanding within the community. He envisions a Springfield where cultural differences are celebrated rather than feared, and where every resident feels valued and included.
As the November elections approach, the political climate intensifies in Ohio, with national rhetoric around immigration increasingly polarizing. DeWine remains firm in his stance, advocating a message of inclusion—one that echoes his party's historical legacy but is often overshadowed by modern political strategies.
In quiet moments, as the DeWines reflect on their journey thus far, they are reminded of their shared commitment to helping others. Their charitable work in Haiti has given them a unique perspective on the struggles faced by immigrants, fostering compassion in the face of adversity.
In Springfield, they find themselves at the intersection of history and modern challenges, grappling with an urgent need for empathy in an increasingly charged political landscape. As debates rage on both local and national stages, DeWine resolutely focuses on actionable solutions that transcend political affiliations.
“Social harmony is essential,” he emphasizes, understanding that long-term solutions require a commitment to collaboration among community members, local leaders, and state officials. His proactive approach aims to quell the tension, providing a model for addressing immigrant issues that other states might look to as a blueprint.
Ultimately, in a state embroiled in political division, DeWine’s balanced perspective provides a counter-narrative—one rooted in compassion and understanding. As the sun sets on Springfield, the governor remains steadfast in his mission to build bridges and foster a community where everyone has the opportunity to thrive, regardless of where they come from. With every step he takes, DeWine reaffirms his commitment: to listen, to learn, and to lead—ensuring that the voices of both longtime residents and new arrivals resonate in the conversation of what it means to be an Ohioan.
Sanya Singh for TROIB News
The DeWines keep to themselves, and most in the sanctuary are unaware of the governor's presence until after the homily when a Haitian layman recognizes him. Curiosity shifts eyes toward the governor, and the congregation rises to give him an ovation. DeWine acknowledges the gesture with a wave before sitting down, heartened to see more Haitians in attendance this week compared to the last, when fear kept many away.
The following morning, the DeWines visit McGregor Metal, a family-run factory that manufactures auto and farm parts. Owner Jamie McGregor has closed the bay doors for safety reasons, as flyers labeling him a “TRAITOR” circulate due to his employment of Haitians and his commendation of their work ethic.
After touring the factory and engaging with a diverse workforce of white Ohioans and Haitians, DeWine joins a discussion at a conference table. The locals praise their co-workers, and one even lightens the mood with a humorous remark about their ancestors. The Haitians express gratitude for their jobs but acknowledge the recent difficulties and the unease surrounding them.
One Haitian, opting to remain anonymous, bravely addresses the governor: “What do they think about the Haitians in Springfield and USA?”
DeWine responds warmly, stating, “Look, people that want to come here and want to work and that are legal, which you are, we welcome you. Everybody, their family came from somewhere. My family, on my father’s side, came from Ireland back in the 1840s.” He reiterates his welcoming stance before inquiring about the challenges they face.
Later that day, DeWine is at the local Bureau of Motor Vehicles, trying to tackle the issues that arise from the growing Haitian population. As he enters the facility, a passerby calls him “a disgrace,” but he remains unfazed. However, inside, frustration builds as he notes the delays in translating driving forms into Creole. “This is not tolerable,” he expresses to his staff, urging them to expedite the process.
DeWine views the challenges as part of a broader “crisis” affecting the area, and he is committed to addressing them. Amid heightened political tensions, especially with immigrant groups being targeted, DeWine's position has become increasingly complex.
While he navigates these issues, DeWine remains focused on solutions, even as he faces pushback from political figures like Senator JD Vance, who uses inflammatory rhetoric against immigrants. DeWine has personal ties to the Haitian community, having quietly supported a Catholic school in one of Port-au-Prince’s poorest neighborhoods for over 20 years.
Mike and Fran DeWine have visited Haiti multiple times and have developed deep connections to its people. They have facilitated fundraising efforts for the Becky DeWine School, named in memory of their late daughter. They dismiss any notion of divine intervention in his current role as governor amidst the unrest in Springfield, emphasizing that he would act similarly for any group of migrants.
DeWine strongly disapproves of claims labeling Haitians as "illegal" immigrants, asserting their lawful status through Temporary Protected Status. He believes the country has historically provided refuge for those fleeing oppression and should continue to do so.
Even as tensions rise, DeWine remains committed to his party's political realities, stating his need to work from within to push for progress. Despite the challenges, he maintains support for Trump while acknowledging the divisive language that has emerged around immigration.
Local leaders, including Mayor Rob Rue, express frustration with the toxic atmosphere cultivated by political rhetoric surrounding Haitian migrants. Tensions surface with increased public safety fears, including a tragic incident involving a Haitian individual. DeWine and Fran empathize with grieving families and emphasize the need for community healing.
As Springfield grapples with its changing demographic landscape, both DeWines witness firsthand the strain on the community. Even as they navigate political dynamics, their focus remains on fostering unity and addressing the everyday needs of their constituents.
The DeWines, well-versed in Ohio's history, reflect on the current challenges facing Springfield. They understand the cyclical nature of immigration and backlash in American history and advocate for a nation that remains a welcoming haven for those seeking opportunity.
In an environment rife with tension and political strife, DeWine voices an enduring belief in the value of immigrants, asserting that their contributions are vital to the country's vitality.As DeWine navigates these complexities, he consistently emphasizes the importance of community engagement and open dialogue. During a recent gathering at a local church, he listens attentively to the concerns of both Haitian immigrants and long-time residents, fostering a sense of solidarity among attendees. It's clear that the governor understands the critical need for communication to bridge the gap between the evolving demographics and the existing population's fears.
Amid these discussions, DeWine highlights initiatives aimed at improving resources for the immigrant community, including language services and emergency support. He acknowledges the existing strain on local institutions, particularly the Bureau of Motor Vehicles, that are struggling to keep up with the volume of new Haitian residents needing assistance. “We have to ensure our systems can accommodate everyone,” he asserts, advocating for accelerating translation services and streamlining processes to ease the burden on all residents.
In Springfield, there’s also a palpable sense of solidarity among many community members who actively support their newly arrived Haitian neighbors. Grassroots organizations, alongside churches and local businesses, are coming together to provide aid and assistance, fostering a sense of belonging among the Haitians. Social gatherings and cultural exchanges are becoming more commonplace, creating a rich dialogue about shared experiences and mutual goals.
DeWine’s outreach extends beyond mere logistical support; he actively champions the contributions of the Haitian community to the local economy. He often cites the hard work and resilience of Haitian immigrants, not only in the manufacturing sector but also in revitalizing local eateries, providing services, and enriching Springfield’s cultural diversity. His commitment to these communities resonates with residents who appreciate the collaborative efforts to nurture unity and pride in their town.
However, DeWine also recognizes that deep-rooted fears and misconceptions persist. He openly addresses the misinformation spread by certain political figures, asserting that the narrative surrounding immigrants has often been mischaracterized. He believes in promoting a more nuanced understanding among constituents, which includes education on the history and contributions of immigrant groups in Ohio.
To further this cause, DeWine pushes for educational programs aimed at children and adults alike that highlight the benefits of diversity, fostering empathy and understanding within the community. He envisions a Springfield where cultural differences are celebrated rather than feared, and where every resident feels valued and included.
As the November elections approach, the political climate intensifies in Ohio, with national rhetoric around immigration increasingly polarizing. DeWine remains firm in his stance, advocating a message of inclusion—one that echoes his party's historical legacy but is often overshadowed by modern political strategies.
In quiet moments, as the DeWines reflect on their journey thus far, they are reminded of their shared commitment to helping others. Their charitable work in Haiti has given them a unique perspective on the struggles faced by immigrants, fostering compassion in the face of adversity.
In Springfield, they find themselves at the intersection of history and modern challenges, grappling with an urgent need for empathy in an increasingly charged political landscape. As debates rage on both local and national stages, DeWine resolutely focuses on actionable solutions that transcend political affiliations.
“Social harmony is essential,” he emphasizes, understanding that long-term solutions require a commitment to collaboration among community members, local leaders, and state officials. His proactive approach aims to quell the tension, providing a model for addressing immigrant issues that other states might look to as a blueprint.
Ultimately, in a state embroiled in political division, DeWine’s balanced perspective provides a counter-narrative—one rooted in compassion and understanding. As the sun sets on Springfield, the governor remains steadfast in his mission to build bridges and foster a community where everyone has the opportunity to thrive, regardless of where they come from. With every step he takes, DeWine reaffirms his commitment: to listen, to learn, and to lead—ensuring that the voices of both longtime residents and new arrivals resonate in the conversation of what it means to be an Ohioan.
Sanya Singh for TROIB News
